The episode opens with a 1971 flashback showing a young Fiona Goode murdering her predecessor, Anna Leigh Leighton, to secure the role of Supreme. In the present, Fiona suspects Madison Montgomery is the next Supreme and, after testing her powers, slits her throat to prevent herself from fading.
Zoe attempts to return the resurrected Kyle to his mother, Alicia Spencer. However, the reunion turns dark when it is revealed Alicia was sexually abusive; Kyle eventually bludgeons her to death with a trophy.
Madison and Nan meet their new neighbor, Luke Ramsey, leading to a fiery confrontation with his devout mother, Joan. Meanwhile, Fiona forces the immortal racist Delphine LaLaurie to serve as Queenie's personal slave.