It is best used for their specialty pizzas rather than just cheese, maximizing the savings.
It works consistently on both dine-in and sometimes carry-out, making it a reliable, high-value option.
If you are looking for a high-quality pizza night that doesn't break the bank, the Old Chicago BOGO deal is worth it. It’s hard to beat premium, fresh-made pizza for effectively half price.
Using the deal in the restaurant adds to the experience. It has a casual, comfortable "taproom" vibe.