Kay Jewelers Buy Back May 2026

Typically only applies to diamond jewelry, not necessarily all gemstones or silver.

You can exchange jewelry for a different item within 60 days. Pros and Cons of the Trade-In Program kay jewelers buy back

If you recently purchased an item and simply want your money back, you must act within their standard return window: Typically only applies to diamond jewelry, not necessarily

This is a mail-in service rather than an instant in-store transaction. You request a secure shipping kit, send your items, and receive an offer based on the scrap weight and purity of the precious metal. Typically only applies to diamond jewelry