Famous for being boiled and then baked in a carousel oven from 1947. Users on Facebook and Reddit often call these the best choice for shipping. Directions Ess-a-Bagel Bagel shop OpenNew York, NY
A staple since 1914, providing high-end smoked fish and traditionally crafted bagels. Directions H&H Bagels $10–20Bagel shop OpenNew York, NY buy new york bagels online
Known for being thick, chewy, and "quintessential". They offer full kits including kosher bagels, lox, and specialized spreads. Directions Russ & Daughters $10–20Bagel shop ClosedNew York, NY Famous for being boiled and then baked in